Table 1: Merits and Limitations of Nonwovens against Wovens|
Merits | Limitations |
|
Lower Labour Employment | High Cost of Equipments |
|
Shorter processing sequence | Few Indigenous manufacturers of repute |
|
High Production rates | Need to develop market |
|
Ability to process recycled and waste fibres | Lower Tensile and Tear strength |
|
Wider width of fabrics up to 10-25m possible | Low Abrasion Resistance |
|
Non directional properties of fabric due to random orientation of fibres | Lower life (Very enhanced in blankets and carpets) |
|
Higher In-plane Water permeability (especially with needle punched) | Pilling tendency and boll formation |
|
Higher filtration Efficiency (especially with needle punched) | Low strength utilisation of fibres |
|
Ability to take the shape of the surface on which it is laid | Lack of technical and marketing personnel with adequate knowledge and experience |
|
Higher Friction to soil | Lack of trained operatives and fitters |
|
Less expensive, hygienic and more versatile especially in wipes | Low strength and unsuitability for rough usage |
|
Ability to utilise the properties of fibres in a better way | Difficulty in getting spare parts |
The relative merits of woven and nonwoven geotextiles is discussed elsewhere1,2. Parikh et al3 compare woven gauze with spunlace nonwoven for medical and surgical applictions3. The above comparisons do not mean that nonwoven is a substitute for woven Rather nonwoven represents a means for exploiting he properties of fibres to meet the unique needs of certain applications. Nonwoven should be considered as a supplement for enrichment of existing textiles. Jute fabric backing under a nonwoven felt gives dimensional stability to floor carpet. Package tray and seat covers made by punching nonwoven on a HDPE woven fabric have strength, comfort and dimensional stability. Woven scrim cloth is sandwiched between needle punched nonwoven felts in filters and blankets. The purpose of scrim cloth is to provide dimensional stability to the product. In some geotextile applications, woven fabric has to be sandwiched between needle punched nonwovens to meet the diverse requirements of strength and permeability. Improved canal liner is made by a composite made out of LDPE film sandwiched between a HDPE woven tape and a nonwoven fabric. Nonwoven fabric minimises damage to film caused by gravel and reduces slippage of cement laid on it4 while HDPE woven tape gives strength to it.
Two basic methods of batt formation are wet and dry laid technology. Later spun bonding and meltblown technology were developed as alternative methods of batt formation. Table 2 :Merits and Limitations of Card � Crosslapping and Air laying
| Carding Crosslapping | Air Laying |
|
Very wide widths of fabrics up to 15-20 metres are possible | Width is limited up to 2-3 metres |
|
A wide range of fabric weights from 75 to 2500gsm are possible by varying take-off speed of laying lattice in relation to speed of delivery lattice | GSM lower than 150 are not normally possible |
|
Highly uniform Fabrics can be made in respect of weight per unit length. Variations in weight per unit length in longitudinal and lateral directions are within 5% | It is difficult to achieve good uniformity in weight/unit length particularly in low weight nonwovens |
|
Ability to process a wide range of staple lengths | Mainly suitable for short fibres. With long fibres it is difficult to get satisfactory uniformity |
|
There is no randomisation between lateral and vertical planes. Anisotropy in strength is also present in the lateral plane. Strength is generally higher in cross direction than longitudinal direction though this is minimised to some extent by the use of randomising rollers in carding and web drafting prior to bonding | Fibre orientation is random in all the 3 dimensions though longitudinal direction strength is slightly higher than cross direction strength. The isotropic distribution gives a high degree of insulation properties. But strength is reduced as fibres in the vertical direction do not contribute to strength. Further anisotropic material cannot be made
Batt formation involving carding |
Batt forming from web coming out of card can be done either by parallel laying or crosslapping.
Table 3 : Relative merits of card - crosslapper cross laying and parallel laying|
Cross laying | Parallel Laying |
|
Very wide widths of nonwovens up to 30m can be formed | Width is restricted by card width. as a result widths beyond 2 � 4 m are not possible |
|
Greater uniformity in strength between longitudinal and cross direction. CD/MD ratio up to 1 : 1.3 can be obtained by use of randomising and condensing rollers in card and web drafting | Cross direction strength is very low in relation to longitudinal direction. MD/CD ratio is 8-10 times |
|
A wide range of weights are possible from 50 to 1500gsm | Only light weights can be made.Weights beyond 100 gsm are not possible |
|
Investment is high as Machinery costs are high | Investment is low and second hand cards disposed by spinning mils are easily available |
Batt UniformityTable 5 : Relative merits of filament bonded and staple fibre bonded Nonwovens|
Spun Bonding | Staple fibre bonding |
|
Higher strength | Lower Strength |
|
Lower Elongation | Higher Elongation |
|
Higher Uniformity in thickness and gsm | Lower uniformity in thickness and gsm |
|
Lacking in textile character and feel | Has good textile character and feel |
|
Higher tear strength | Lower tear strength |
|
Products are normally of low to medium gsm (20 � 250) | Wide range of products from low to medium to high gsm are available (20 � 1500) |
|
Less flexibility in regard to raw material. Generally line is suitable for either polypropylene or polyester or Nylon or bicomponent fibre. Some latest models however claim flexibility in regard to fibre All types of raw material can be processed in the same line | All types of fibres, manmade and natural can be made in the same line |
|
High Plant capacity in terms of production | Low to medium capacity in terms of production |
|
High capital investment | Low to Medium capital investment |
Major Applications
1.Coverstock for diapers and hygiene products
2.Surgical materials
3.Carpet backing
4.Bedding and furniture
5.Geotextiles
6.Roof Materials and other construction material
7.Filters
8.Industrial products
Meltblown Nonwoven
Melblown nonwoven is batt formed of ultra fine filaments deposited on a screen. Polymer is extruded through a die consisting of several hundred holes.(Fig 23) Streams of hot air at temp of 220 to 3400C, passing from an outer channels of the die, rapidly attenuate the extruded polymer at 0.5 o 0.7 times the speed of sound, to form extremely fine micro filaments. The filaments are quenched by cool air flowing from the contours of the die and blown on to collector screen thus forming a self bonded nonwoven batt. The fibres are bonded together because of interlacing action of deposition and thermal bonding by the hot air. The meltblown material has low strength and is often used in combination with other nonwoven material. Because of the ultra fine size of the filaments and increase in specific surface area, meltblown material has a high filtration efficiency for gas and liquids and particles.
Barrier material is formed by combining meltblown material with spunbonded. Absorbents are made by combining cellulose or wood pulp with meltblown material Meltblown material sandiwiched between two layers of spunbonded materials, known as sms nonwovens are widely used as hospital gowns, hygiene, and filtration products. SMMS are also sometimes made.
Meltblown
Fig 23 Meltblown Process
Process Checkpoints
1. Viscosity of polymer chips should be checked in viscosity meter.
2.The spinnerets and other parts of the spinning system must be thoroughly cleaned of polymer build-up at periodic intervals and at the time pack change. When polymer build up contaminates the parts, production has to be brought down to maintain satisfactory processing. The quality of product also gets adversely affected by presence of defects like stripes, bars and doglegs. Traditional cleaning consists of 1 burning the hardened polymer by placing the spinneret in a furnace 2. Cleaning in an ultrasonic bath of caustic soda and 3. spray bath cleaning. This method is time consuming and there is risk of spinneret damage. The vacuum pyrolysis process of cleaning is much more rapid and ensures defect free thorough cleaning
3. Spinnerets should be examined under magnification for wear and tear. Preferably, an automated spinneret examination system should be used to inspect the spinneret at the time of purchase and during use to ensure that the design specifications are maintained as this speeds up the process. If the holes of the spinneret show signs of wear they should be refurbished.
References
1. Nonwovens � Technoogy of manufacture and properties
A.K. Rakshit, A.N. Desai and N. Balasubramanian, Proceedings of Symposium on Nonwovens, BTRA, 1987, Feb
2. A comparison of woven and nonwoven geotextiles,
J. Perfetti, Meliand Textilber (Eng. Edn.), 1985, March, p207
3.Woven and Nonwoven medical/surgical materials
D.V.Parikh, T.A.Calamari, A.P.S.Sawhney, N.D.Sachinwala, W.R.Goynes, J.M.Hemstreet, and T. Van Hoven, International Nonwovens J, 1999 Spring
4. Development of a geocomposite canal liner � BTRA�S experience
A.N.Desai and N.Balasubramanian, J. Textile Association, 1991 Jan, p187
5. http://www.inda.org/wet-laid.html
6. Relative merits of polypropylene and polyester
N.Balasubramanian, Indian Textile J, 2004, 32, p32
7. Influence of processing conditions on functional properties of high loft structures
A.N.Desai and N.Balasubramanian, Indian J of Fibre and Textile Research, 1990, 15, p169
8. Opening size and water permeability of nonwoven geotextile
A.K.Rakshit and N.Balasubramanian, Indian Textile J., 1991 June, p 26
9. Indian Textile J, 2009, July, p 71
10. http://www.texdata.com/content/0082e.pdf